The true embodiment of 1920s sophistication, this captivating Colonial masterpiece known as 19 Hilltop Place in Rye, NY is a spectacular blend of classic grandeur and contemporary luxury. Once home to former Bergdorf Goodman owner Andrew Goodman for almost 50 years, 19 Hilltop Place enjoys a wonderful history in the NYC fashion world.  

A lifestyle like no other can be enjoyed in this private breathtaking setting.

Boasting a 9,000+ square foot Main House, a 1,100+ square foot Pool House and an 800 + square foot Guest House on 2.6 private gated and fully fenced acres, the estate features exceptional amenities: an  in-ground pool with expansive entertainment sized pool area including large outdoor kitchen with island seating, stunning formal gardens, tennis and bocce courts, and amazing “garden to table” raised bed vegetable gardens.

With a meticulous, to-the-studs renovation and expansion of the Main House in the late 1990s, an updated Guest House, and newly built Pool and Pool House in 2006, all thoughtfully reimagined and upgraded by its current owners, every contemporary convenience has been seamlessly integrated into the space while preserving the original architectural splendor. This is nothing short of a full resort-style experience.  

From the moment you enter the front-to-back Entrance Hall, natural light and graceful proportions define the space.

The second floor boasts an exceptional primary suite with a centerpiece fireplace and breathtaking views of the grounds and golf course beyond from the private balcony, with a large bedroom and a sitting room, dual dressing rooms and baths.

An additional three bedrooms with study/ play areas attached, two with en-suite baths, and a third with a hall bath directly across all enjoy golf course views and expansive views of the back lawns. An additional fifth bedroom/ exercise room with adjacent half bath and open sitting area enjoys front courtyard and garden views. The third floor offers two additional bedrooms with large hall bath, both with stunning garden and golf course views. A flexible floor plan to suit any family’s needs!  

The Pool House offers a full kitchen, living room, two bathrooms, and two changing rooms with six French doors opening to the oversized pool terrace and back terrace overlooking the bocce court. The Guest House, adjacent to the vegetable garden, offers an eat-in kitchenette, two bedrooms, a living room, and two bathrooms. 

Outside, the estate truly shines.

Throughout the expansive grounds, mature trees and carefully pruned shrubs add a sense of permanence and beauty.

19 Hilltop Place in Rye, NY is proudly listed by Donna and Scott McElwee. To view the listing and take a virtual tour, click here.  And don’t miss the property’s custom website for an additional peak into this extraordinary lifestyle at NineteenHilltop.com.